One Thing You Lack: Mark 10 on the Man Who Walked Away Sad and What We Will Not Let Go

He ran to Jesus, fell on his knees and walked away sad. Here is what Mark 10 teaches about the love in Jesus' look, the one thing that held a good man, and what only God can do with what we will not let go.

The Man Who Ran

Few scenes in the Gospels begin this well and end this badly. A man runs up to Jesus on the road and drops to his knees in the dirt. He has a real question, and he has brought it to the right person.

We usually call him the rich young ruler, but that name is stitched together from three accounts. Matthew tells us he was young (Matthew 19:20). Luke tells us he was a ruler (Luke 18:18). Mark tells us neither, and he holds back the man's money until the last line of the encounter. So in Mark we meet the eagerness first. We see a man who wants what he does not have, and we like him.

Then we watch him leave slowly, with the answer he asked for and no desire to act on it.

The Question Under the Story

This passage is usually taught as a warning about money, and it is one. But a warning can be held at arm's length. Most of us can name someone richer than we are, and we hand the warning to them.

Mark does not let us do that, because the center of this story is a look. Before Jesus says the hardest thing He ever says to one person about possessions, He looks at the man and loves him. That changes the question a steward has to ask. The question is no longer only what I own. It is what I would refuse to hand to Someone who loves me, if He asked.

Lesson One: The Right Person and the Wrong Question

Mark sets the scene quickly. "As Jesus started on his way, a man ran up to him and fell on his knees before him. 'Good teacher,' he asked, 'what must I do to inherit eternal life?'" (Mark 10:17, NIV).

He asks what he must do to inherit. But nobody does anything to inherit. An inheritance comes from who you are to the one who is giving it. This man has spent his life achieving and keeping, and he brings that habit to the one question it cannot answer. He wants the item that is missing from the list.

Only a few verses earlier, Jesus has been holding children and telling the crowd that the kingdom must be received the way a little child receives (Mark 10:13-16). Then this man arrives, ready to do.

Jesus answers his greeting first. "'Why do you call me good?' Jesus answered. 'No one is good—except God alone.'" (Mark 10:18, NIV).

This is not Jesus denying who He is. He is stopping the man at the word. You say good too easily, He is saying. You are using it as a compliment between two respectable men. Goodness belongs to God, and measuring yourself against Him is a different exercise from measuring yourself against your neighbors.

Before the man can hear about what he lacks, he has to learn what scale he is standing on. Most of us grade ourselves against the people nearby, and we come out fine. Jesus points us to the only standard that has never needed grading.

Lesson Two: All These I Have Kept

Jesus takes him to the commandments he already knows. "You know the commandments: 'You shall not murder, you shall not commit adultery, you shall not steal, you shall not give false testimony, you shall not defraud, honor your father and mother.'" (Mark 10:19, NIV).

Two details deserve attention. Every command on this list concerns how we treat other people. The ones about loving God first are left out, and so is the command against coveting. Jesus will come back to those without naming them. And Mark's list includes one line that is not in the Ten Commandments in that form: you shall not defraud. It may stand in for coveting, the sin of a person with means, who can take from others with a contract instead of a crowbar.

The man's answer comes quickly. "'Teacher,' he declared, 'all these I have kept since I was a boy.'" (Mark 10:20, NIV).

Do not sneer at him. Jesus doesn't. He does not call the man a liar or a hypocrite. There is every reason to think this man paid his workers, told the truth and was kind to his parents.

That is what makes him so close to home. A person can keep every visible rule and still feel the gap. He has done everything, and he still ran down the road. Something in him knows the list is finished and the question is still open. His restlessness is one of the most honest things about him.

If you have been faithful for years and still feel that same ache, do not assume it is a failure. It may be the very thing bringing you to His feet.

Lesson Three: Jesus Looked at Him and Loved Him

Now comes the sentence that only Mark records. "Jesus looked at him and loved him. 'One thing you lack,' he said. 'Go, sell everything you have and give to the poor, and you will have treasure in heaven. Then come, follow me.'" (Mark 10:21, NIV).

Read the order slowly. The look comes first, then the love, then the demand. Jesus knows what He is about to say, and He knows how the man will answer. He loves him anyway, before the answer and regardless of it. Nothing in the text suggests the love was withdrawn when the man walked away.

This reframes every hard word God has ever spoken to you. We tend to hear a demand from God as a sign of displeasure. Mark shows us the opposite. The hardest command in this story comes out of love, and it comes because of love. A doctor who loves you will name the tumor. "Wounds from a friend can be trusted, but an enemy multiplies kisses." (Proverbs 27:6, NIV).

Jesus could have flattered him. He could have accepted this wealthy, respectable, eager man as a fine addition to a poor band of Galileans. Any fundraiser would have. A movement with few resources just met a man with many, and Jesus risks losing him in a single sentence.

He tells him the truth because He wants the man, not the money. When God puts His finger on the thing you have been protecting, the first thing to know is that He is looking at you the way He looked at this man.

Lesson Four: The Hand That Would Not Open

The command lands, and the story turns. "At this the man's face fell. He went away sad, because he had great wealth." (Mark 10:22, NIV).

The word for his face falling is the one Matthew uses for a sky turning dark (Matthew 16:3). A cloud moved across him. And here, at last, Mark tells us about the money. He has been saving it for this line, because it explains everything. The list was never the problem. He could keep ten commands and could not release one thing.

We should be honest about what this command is and is not. Jesus said this to this man. Scripture does not read it as a rule for every believer. Zacchaeus gave half and Jesus declared salvation had come to his house (Luke 19:1-10). Women of means supported Jesus from their own resources (Luke 8:1-3). Paul told the rich to be generous and rich in good deeds, and he did not tell them to liquidate (1 Timothy 6:17-19).

Nor is selling a way to buy eternal life. Scripture settles that. "For it is by grace you have been saved, through faith—and this is not from yourselves, it is the gift of God— not by works, so that no one can boast." (Ephesians 2:8-9, NIV).

But do not use those facts to get out of the room. Jesus has just reached past the second table of the law to the first. Love God first. Do not covet. His wealth was in God's place, and Jesus named it. The real command in verse 21 is the last one: come, follow me. The selling cleared the road.

So the question passes to us. It may not be money. It may be a title, a reputation, a house or a plan. What is the one thing that would make your face fall?

Lesson Five: Who Then Can Be Saved?

Jesus watches the man go and turns to His own. "Jesus looked around and said to his disciples, 'How hard it is for the rich to enter the kingdom of God!'" (Mark 10:23, NIV).

This shocked them. Much of their world took wealth as evidence of God's favor. If anyone was on the inside, it was a man like that. "The disciples were amazed at his words. But Jesus said again, 'Children, how hard it is to enter the kingdom of God! It is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for someone who is rich to enter the kingdom of God.'" (Mark 10:24-25, NIV).

He calls these grown men children, and the tenderness matters. Then He reaches for the largest animal they knew and the smallest opening. You may have heard that the needle was a low gate in Jerusalem that a camel could squeeze through on its knees. There is no good ancient evidence for such a gate, and the story misses the point. Jesus is describing something impossible, and the disciples hear it that way.

"The disciples were even more amazed, and said to each other, 'Who then can be saved?'" (Mark 10:26, NIV).

That is exactly the right question. If the best-placed man in town cannot get in, nobody can. And Jesus does not soften it. "Jesus looked at them and said, 'With man this is impossible, but not with God; all things are possible with God.'" (Mark 10:27, NIV).

There is the third look in this passage, and it carries the gospel. No one can pry their own fingers off what they love. The man could not do it, and neither can we. The opening of a closed hand is something God does. That is why this passage, for all its severity, is good news for anyone who has tried and failed to let go.

Lesson Six: A Hundred Times as Much

Peter has been doing the math. "Then Peter spoke up, 'We have left everything to follow you!'" (Mark 10:28, NIV). You can hear both the pride and the worry. He is thinking of the boat and the nets, and of a home in Capernaum. What about us?

Jesus does not scold him. "'Truly I tell you,' Jesus replied, 'no one who has left home or brothers or sisters or mother or father or children or fields for me and the gospel will fail to receive a hundred times as much in this present age: homes, brothers, sisters, mothers, children and fields—along with persecutions—and in the age to come eternal life.'" (Mark 10:29-30, NIV).

This is no promise of a hundredfold return on your giving, and it should never be preached as one. Nobody receives a hundred mothers by writing a check. Jesus is describing the family of God: a people whose homes are open to you, whose tables you sit at, who become your brothers and sisters when your own have turned away.

Mark alone adds two words that no prosperity teacher wants: along with persecutions. The new family comes with the cost of belonging to Jesus in a world that resists Him.

And look at the last phrase. Eternal life. It is the very thing the man ran down the road to ask about, and Jesus hands it to the people who are holding nothing. The inheritance goes to those who stopped trying to acquire it.

"But many who are first will be last, and the last first." (Mark 10:31, NIV). The man in the road looked first. Twelve tired fishermen and tax collectors looked last. It will not stay that way.

For Business Leaders: Name What You Will Not Put on the Table

Every serious leader knows the difference between assets you would sell and assets you would never touch. Somewhere in your life there is a line you have drawn without saying so. Everything above it is available to God. Below it sits the valuation, the title on the door, the exit you have been planning, the one account you never mention.

Jesus did not ask this man for a percentage. He went straight to the line. You may never be asked to sell the company. But a stewardship that has a protected category is a partnership on your terms, and He does not sign those.

"What good is it for someone to gain the whole world, yet forfeit their soul?" (Mark 8:36, NIV).

Your Obedience Step

Write down the one asset, position or plan you would struggle most to give up if God asked. Do not sell anything yet. Take that page to one trusted believer this week, tell them what is on it, and pray over it together.

For Community Leaders: Do Not Be Overawed by the Donor

Jesus let a wealthy man walk away from a movement that needed money. Most of us who lead churches and nonprofits would have followed him down the road with an alternative proposal.

It is hard to tell the truth to the person who funds the roof. Leaders soften sermons, avoid names and overlook conduct, all without quite admitting why. Loving the generous well means telling them what you would tell anyone else. Sometimes it means letting them leave sad.

"Do not be overawed when others grow rich, when the splendor of their houses increases; for they will take nothing with them when they die, their splendor will not descend with them." (Psalm 49:16-17, NIV).

Your Obedience Step

Think of the largest supporter of your work. Ask yourself what you have avoided saying to them, and why. This week, have one honest pastoral conversation with them, or call to ask how their soul is doing with no request attached.

For Home Leaders: The Cost of the Bigger Life

Homes rarely name their one thing. It shows up as the house that needs two incomes and every overtime shift, the lifestyle that has quietly set the family calendar, the fear of what the neighbors would think if you drove an older car. Your children are watching what you will not give up.

Better a smaller life with one another in it. A home is free when it holds its things loosely enough that a call from God would not cause a crisis at the kitchen table.

"Better a small serving of vegetables with love than a fattened calf with hatred." (Proverbs 15:17, NIV).

Your Obedience Step

Sit down with your spouse or household and ask one question: what are we working to keep up that is costing us each other? Choose one expense or commitment to cut this month, and give the money or the time away together.

For the Everyday Believer: Find Out What Would Make Your Face Fall

You may not think of yourself as rich. Most people who read this are, by any measure the man in Mark 10 would have recognized. But the test here has never depended on the size of the balance. A person with little can be held as tightly as a person with much.

So try the question honestly. Imagine Jesus looking at you with love and naming one thing. What do you already hope He does not name? Paul found that losing everything was worth it once he had weighed it against knowing Christ.

"What is more, I consider everything a loss because of the surpassing worth of knowing Christ Jesus my Lord, for whose sake I have lost all things. I consider them garbage, that I may gain Christ" (Philippians 3:8, NIV).

Your Obedience Step

Tonight, name that one thing out loud to God. Then give something real away this week from that same category: money if it is money, time if it is time, credit if it is your reputation. Let it cost enough to notice.

He Is Still Looking at You

Mark never tells us what became of the man. The last we see of him is his back, moving away down the road, sad. The story is left open, and maybe that is deliberate, because it leaves the door open for everyone reading it.

Right after this, Jesus goes on up the road toward Jerusalem and tells His disciples what is waiting there (Mark 10:32-34). The one who asked this man to give up everything was on His way to do exactly that. He asked nothing of the man that He was not about to give Himself.

So the look is the part to hold on to. If He has put His finger on something in your life, He is not angry. He has looked at you and loved you. What you cannot open by yourself, He is able to open. The road He is calling you onto ends at the thing you ran to Him for in the first place.

Questions for Reflection

1. When I picture God asking me to give something up, what do I imagine on His face?
2. What standard have I been using to call myself good, and who am I comparing myself with?
3. If Jesus named my one thing, what do I already suspect it would be?
4. What would be different about my life if that one thing were on the table?
5. Where have I softened the truth to someone because of what they give or what they could take away?
6. How have I experienced the family of God as part of the hundred times as much?

Closing Prayer

Lord Jesus, I have come to you running at times, and I have also walked away. You see what I keep below the line, and you know the thing I hope you never mention. Thank you that you look at me and love me before you ask me for anything. I confess that I have measured my goodness against the people around me, and that I have held tightly to what you only lent me. I cannot open my own hand. With me it is impossible, but all things are possible with you. So do in me what I cannot do. Show me the one thing, and give me the courage to bring it to you. Let me follow you all the way up the road. In Jesus' name, Amen.

The Key to Harbor Street

Caroline Voss kept nineteen keys on her ring, and she could have told you what each one opened. Seventeen were for Voss Plumbing Supply, which her father had started and she had tripled. One was for the house. One was for a brick building on Harbor Street that nobody had asked about in years.

Her father had bought it the year the bank nearly took everything. "You always keep one thing nobody can touch," he told her. It was paid for, empty and insured. She drove past it most Sundays and checked the locks. She had never told her husband what it was worth. It was the thing behind all the other things.

By fifty-eight she had done everything right. She gave fifteen percent. She chaired the church finance committee and sat on the board of Mercy House, which sheltered women and children in eleven rented rooms. And she had stopped sleeping.

So she took it to Walter Ames. Walter was eighty-one, a retired hardware man who had taught her Tuesday Bible study for twenty years, and she trusted him the way she had trusted her father.

"I've done everything I know to do," she said at his kitchen table. "Something's missing. I can't find it."

Walter looked at her for a long time. His eyes were wet, which was only his age, or so she told herself.

"Mercy House lost its lease," he said.

"I know. I'm running the campaign."

"You'll be raising that money for three years." He reached across and laid one finger on her key ring. "Caroline. Give them the building."

She felt it in her stomach before she heard it in her head. She started to explain about her father, and contingency, and fiduciary something. He did not argue. He just kept looking at her, kindly, and that was the part she could not stand.

She drove home and did not go back to Tuesday study.

Eleven months passed. The campaign raised forty percent. Mercy House moved into a motel on the highway. Caroline still checked the locks on Sundays. She told herself Walter was old and had overstepped, and nobody else in the world would have asked her such a thing. She was right about the last part.

In March his daughter called. Caroline wore black, sat near the back, and afterward, in the fellowship hall, the daughter pressed a small spiral notebook into her hands.

"Dad's prayer list," she said. "You should see your page."

It was in his square hardware-store print. There was her name, and under it a column of dates going back eleven months, one for every morning, with a word or two beside each.

"Still angry with me. Lord, I love her. So do You."

"She will not call. Don't let me call. Give her time."

"She can't do this. I know she can't. You can."

The last entry was four days before he died. It read, "Harbor St. Still asking."

She drove there that night and sat in the truck with the ring in her lap. Then she got out, stood under the streetlight and started working the key around the steel loop. It had been on there for nineteen years. Her thumbnail split. She stopped twice.

"I can't," she said out loud, to nobody on the sidewalk. "I can't do this. You know I can't."

She stood there a while longer. Then, for no reason she could ever explain, she tried again, and it came.

She walked it into the night drop at the Mercy House office with a note that said only, "Deed to follow." Her hand kept going to the place on the ring where it had been. It did that for a year.

Mercy House opened on Harbor Street the next fall. On the first Saturday, Caroline came down to help stack cots. A new volunteer with a clipboard saw her waiting on the step and hurried over.

"Sorry, ma'am. Don't you have a key?"

Caroline laughed, and it surprised her how easily it came.

"No," she said. "I knock."

Go Deeper

Ready to put this teaching into practice? The Life That Is Truly Life is a guided workbook drawn from Luke 12, Mark 10, 1 Timothy 6 and Philippians 4. Work through four movements at your own pace and finish with one page you build for yourself: Your Enough Statement.

Get the workbook